top of page

Real Estate Valuation Appeals - A Legal Lesson on Greed and Timeliness

May 29, 2023

In the world of property taxation, an old adage might be more pertinent than you think: "The pig gets fat, but the hog gets slaughtered." This saying encapsulates a lesson that some property owners learn the hard way when dealing with real estate valuation and tax reassessment.

Lesson 1: Beware of Greed

Our first lesson can be summed up by the story of the Villa entities. Faced with a reassessment of their property values, they decided not to accept the revised figures but to appeal, presumably on the advice of their legal counsel. However, this move backfired spectacularly when their appeal failed, leaving them burdened with both the reassessed taxes and hefty attorneys' fees.

This case serves as a cautionary tale for other property owners contemplating an appeal against property valuation. While it's important to ensure you're not being overcharged, it's equally crucial not to let greed guide your decisions. Appeals can be costly and, as the Villa entities learned, there's always a risk that things may not go your way.

Lesson 2: The Double-Edged Sword of Appeals

It's worth noting that filing an appeal can sometimes do more harm than good. This is because appealing the initial valuation of a property essentially opens Pandora's box. The Board then has the authority to determine the correct value of the property, and it could be higher or lower than the original assessment.

Lesson 3: Understand the Process and Your Rights

The statutory scheme gives the appeals board the authority to determine the full value of the property, provided the assessor gives notice of intent to present evidence of a higher valuation. This process involves consideration of evidence submitted by both the assessor and the property owner. Understanding your rights and obligations in this process can help you navigate the appeal process more effectively.

Lesson 4: Laches and the Importance of Timeliness

The legal principle of laches teaches us the importance of promptness when it comes to asserting our rights. Laches is a defense in equity law based on the idea that if you neglect your rights for an unreasonable time, you may be barred from seeking relief. It requires unreasonable delay plus either acquiescence (i.e., agreement without protest) in the act about which the plaintiff complains, or evidence that the delay has prejudiced the defendant.

The lesson here is clear: if you believe you have a valid complaint or appeal, act on it in a timely manner. Not doing so can lead to a loss of potential relief and can cause unnecessary complications for both you and the other party involved.

In conclusion, navigating property taxes and valuations can be a tricky endeavor. Keeping these lessons in mind, and seeking competent legal advice, can go a long way in protecting your interests. Remember, sometimes the biggest lessons in law come from understanding human nature and our inherent tendencies, such as the risks of greed and the value of timeliness. The "hog" who is too greedy or too slow might just end up getting "slaughtered."

This blog post is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Each legal case is unique, and you should consult with a knowledgeable law firm for advice tailored to your specific circumstances and for further assistance with your real estate needs.

8 views0 comments


bottom of page